Book a callWhat Shopify stores get wrong for Merchant Center: data from 4,520 store scans
Original GMC Scout data on the Merchant Center risks found most often on Shopify stores, from 4,520 scans between November 2025 and October 2026.
Most Shopify stores have the policy pages Google expects. What they leave out is the detail inside them. Across 4,520 GMC Scout scans of 2,247 Shopify stores between November 2025 and October 2026, fewer than 4% were missing a shipping, terms or privacy page. But 1 in 4 didn’t say whether a restocking fee applies, and more than 1 in 5 gave no order cut-off time.
Key findings
- Missing policy pages were rare. Missing policy details were not. Under 4% of scans were missing a shipping, terms or privacy page. 25% didn’t state a restocking fee, 23% gave no order cut-off time and 15% didn’t give customer service hours.
- 44% had empty collections: collection pages with no products in them.
- 37% linked to the wrong domain: leftover links to a theme demo, an old domain or another store.
- 30% used a contact email on a different domain to the store, such as a Gmail address on a branded store.
- Basic contact details were often missing. 17% had no phone number, 11% no business address and 7% no email address.
- Broken pages are common too. Since GMC Scout tightened its broken-page check on 4 September 2026, 24% of scans have found at least one 404 page.
The data at a glance
| Measure | Figure |
|---|---|
| Scans | 4,520 |
| Unique Shopify stores | 2,247 |
| Pages scanned | 1,119,161 |
| Period | 11 Nov 2025 – 27 Oct 2026 |
The 15 most common issues
Share of all 4,520 scans in which each issue appeared at least once. Broken pages are reported separately below.
| # | Issue | What it means | Scans affected |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Empty collections | Collection pages with no products | 44.0% |
| 2 | Links to the wrong domain | Links pointing to a demo, old or different domain | 37.0% |
| 3 | Email domain mismatch | Contact email isn’t on the store’s own domain | 30.0% |
| 4 | No restocking fee stated | Return policy doesn’t say whether a restocking fee applies | 25.4% |
| 5 | No order cut-off time | Shipping info doesn’t say when orders must be placed to ship that day | 22.7% |
| 6 | Policy pages hard to find | Policy pages missing from the footer or in the wrong place | 19.8% |
| 7 | No phone number | No store phone number found | 17.2% |
| 8 | Very new domain | Domain registered less than 30 days ago | 16.2% |
| 9 | No customer service hours | Store doesn’t say when support is available | 15.1% |
| 10 | No business address | No store address found | 11.1% |
| 11 | Exchanges not mentioned | Return policy doesn’t say whether exchanges are accepted | 8.1% |
| 12 | Shipping countries not listed | Store doesn’t say where it ships | 7.8% |
| 13 | No refund processing time | Return policy doesn’t say how long refunds take | 7.2% |
| 14 | No contact email | No store email address found | 6.7% |
| 15 | No return shipping cost | Return policy doesn’t say who pays return shipping | 6.3% |
Broken pages (404)
24% of scans run since 4 September 2026 found at least one broken page. Before that date, GMC Scout also flagged contact-page addresses it had only guessed at, which overstated broken pages, so we don’t quote a full-year figure.
Missing pages vs missing details
Almost every store had its policy pages. What was missing was the detail Google and shoppers look for inside them.
| Missing the whole page | Scans | Missing a detail | Scans |
|---|---|---|---|
| Shipping policy | 3.4% | No restocking fee stated | 25.4% |
| Terms of service | 3.4% | No order cut-off time | 22.7% |
| Privacy policy | 2.7% | No customer service hours | 15.1% |
| Returns policy | 0.1% | Exchanges not mentioned | 8.1% |
| No refund processing time | 7.2% | ||
| No return shipping cost | 6.3% | ||
| No return window | 5.2% |
Shopify’s policy templates create the pages. They don’t fill in your real terms.
Missing the whole page
Missing a detail
What to fix first
- One business identity. Same name, email, phone and address everywhere, with an email on your own domain.
- The details inside your policies. Return window, restocking fee, exchanges, return shipping cost, refund timing, order cut-off, delivery times and countries.
- Wrong-domain and broken links. Find every link to a demo or old domain and every 404, and fix or remove them.
- Empty collections. Fill them or unpublish them.
- Policy links in the footer on every page.
Run a free GMC Scout scan to see which of these apply to your store.
Methodology
- Source: GMC Scout, a Shopify storefront scanner that runs 70+ compliance, policy and trust checks commonly associated with Merchant Center review. It reads public pages only and never connects to Merchant Center.
- Sample: 4,520 completed scans of 2,247 unique Shopify stores, 11 November 2025 to 27 October 2026: every completed scan whose full report is stored. Scans by GMC Scout’s own team and test accounts are excluded.
- Unit: percentages are the share of scans in which an issue appeared at least once. Some stores were scanned more than once (about 2 scans per store on average).
- Broken pages: on 4 September 2026 GMC Scout stopped reporting 404s on contact-page addresses it had guessed rather than found. The broken-page figure above uses scans from that date onwards only.
- Domain age: based on the date the store’s domain was first registered, from the public domain registry, on the day of the scan.
- Limits: these are GMC Scout’s checks, not Google’s. Google doesn’t publish its review criteria, and finding an issue doesn’t mean a store was or will be suspended. Stores that use a compliance scanner may differ from Shopify stores in general.
Quick answers
Do most Shopify stores have the policy pages Google expects?
Yes. Under 4% of 4,520 scans were missing a shipping, terms or privacy page. The common gap is missing detail inside the policies, such as restocking fees (25%) and order cut-off times (23%).
What is the most common Merchant Center risk on Shopify stores?
In GMC Scout data, empty collection pages (44% of scans), links to the wrong domain (37%) and a contact email on a different domain to the store (30%).
How common are broken pages on Shopify stores?
24% of GMC Scout scans since 4 September 2026 found at least one broken (404) page.
How many Shopify stores are missing a phone number or address?
17% of scans found no phone number and 11% found no business address.
Use this data
You’re welcome to quote and chart these figures with a link to this page.
Suggested citation: Terry Ecom, “What Shopify stores get wrong for Merchant Center: data from 4,520 store scans”, GMC Scout, October 2026. https://terryecom.com/research/gmc-approval-report-2026/
Terry Ecom is independent and not affiliated with Google. Google makes all Merchant Center decisions.
Not sure what Google is seeing?
Start with a free automated scan, then use the result to prioritise the highest-risk issues.
